More Than Love: Beyond Romance for LGBTQ+

TABLE OF CONTENTS

We’re nearing the end of June which means many companies will soon be putting away their rainbow products, removing rainbow signs from their storefronts and the rest of the month’s self‑serving pink washing1 will be yesterday’s news. But what does that mean for LGBTQ+ (lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans, queer or questioning) visibility in the media year‑round? And regardless of the time of year, are we even getting it right?

For most of the marketing and advertising industry, progress with LGBTQ+ representation featuring real people has been slow, clunky and often one‑dimensional. The first mainstream LGBTQ+ ad appearing in the United States premiered 25 years ago, in 1994 courtesy of Ikea. The spot was titled “Dining Room”2 and featured a gay male couple shopping for furniture for their home. It aired in three markets (Washington D.C., Philadelphia, New York City) after 10 PM to “avoid family hour programming” and even with that concession, was still widely protested. The creative director at Deutsch – the agency behind the campaign – believed that this was the dawn of a new era in advertising and that many brands would follow in their footsteps.

Yet, what’s happened in the years since has been less deluge, more stagnant trickle. In 2012, Ray‑Ban’s “Never Hide” campaign for their 75th anniversary celebration featured two “English gentleman” holding hands.3 That same year, Gap featured two young men snuggled in a t‑shirt as part of their “Be One” campaign.4 In 2013, Amazon Kindle showed a gay married couple on vacation.5 In 2014, a Cheerios ad6 released in Canada featured two gay dads and their adopted daughter. In 2015, another set of gay dads with their adopted daughter were featured in an ad for Campbell’s.7 In 2016, Airbnb’s “Don’t Go There, Live There” campaign shows two moms and their children visiting Los Angeles.8 Noticing a pattern yet? We do. To this day, much of LGBTQ+ advertising orbits a very heteronormative romantic path: find your spouse, get married, have 2.5 kids. Rinse, repeat.

More often than not, advertising is a pulse of the social, political or cultural conversation of the day. As “Love is Love” and “Love Wins” became the official tag lines of our modern movement for “gay rights” – a movement largely anchored by a push for same‑sex marriage equality – so followed LGBTQ+ advertising, with a focus on highlighting gay and lesbian couples and families. But this pattern – however well‑intentioned and successful in bringing some of the LGBTQ+ community into the fold of “social acceptability” – also inadvertently perpetuates a flattened and reductive representation of LGBTQ+ identity. What’s more is that as with many of our broad social discussions about the LGBTQ+ community, the centering of these mostly white, mostly cisgender couples harmfully exclude those among us who are trans and non‑binary as well almost all QTPOC (queer and trans people of color).

Bisexual black woman in a good mood smiling with hands on her face. Part of the LGBTQ Portrait series.
1150513204, Willie B. Thomas
900941018, Daniel Tardif

Some brands and advertisers are starting to get the point. Abercrombie and Fitch recently highlighted their long‑standing partnership with The Trevor Project for an evolution of their “#FaceYourFierce” campaign9 to showcase their continued support of LGBTQ+ youth in crisis. The campaign features a diverse array of LGBTQ+ public figures sharing their personal stories including Phillip Picardi (Editor‑In‑Chief of Out Magazine), Crystal Anderson (Producer at Man Repeller), TJ (Model and Activist) and many more. On the beauty side, Sephora celebrated the transgender and non‑binary community with their incredibly moving “We Belong to Something Beautiful” campaign10 featuring an inclusive cast of trans, non‑binary, genderqueer, gender fluid, gender non‑conforming individuals including Aaron Philip (Model), Hunter Schafer (Model, Actress and Activist) and Precious Ebony (Actress, Rapper and Ball Host). And finally, from the CPG space, Gillette shared a heartwarming promotional video depending the tender intimacy between a father and his transgender son as the son learns to shave following his transition.

The fact is: members of the LGBTQ+ community live incredibly full, rich lives both within and outside of their romantic and/or sexual interests. They work, they laugh, they cry, they have friends, they go out, they go to school, they drink, they’re sober, they love their biological families, they redefine family for themselves, they marry, they partner, they opt for non‑monogamous relationships, they have children, they choose not to have children, they explore gender performance, they align with their gender assignment at birth, they forgo the gender construct completely, they find love, they opt out of love and so much more. The possibilities are infinite and thus, should be fully reflected in our media. We hope that with all of the important dialogue being had and more brands taking a different tack, we are truly at the beginning of a new era.

Tristen Norman
Director and Head of Creative Insights, The Americas
Tristen is a visual researcher and strategic creative lead for the Americas at Getty Images. Leaning on over a decade of experience in marketing, creative, and brand strategy, she works across disciplines to understand what motivates visual selection, identify shifts in our global visual language and uses these insights to help shape the development of Getty’s visual content and guide brands to better visual choices. A passionate advocate for elevating underrepresented voices within creative spaces, she also plays an essential role in leading and supporting initiatives such as the Nosotros Collection, Project #ShowUs, as well as partnerships and activations with advocacy organizations like SEEHER, Women’s Sports Foundation and GLAAD.

WORKS CITED

1) Pink washing (Twitter User @fransquishco)
2) Dining Room commercial (YouTube)
3) Ray‑Ban's 'Never Hide' Campaign Features Gay Male Couple For First Time (The Huffington Post)
4) Gap Unveils New Ad Featuring Same‑Sex Couple (Out)
5) Amazon Kindle Paperwhite TV Spot, 'Husbands' (iSpot)
6) The Cheerios Effect (YouTube)
7) Campbell Soup Gay Parents Ad (YouTube)
8) Airbnb TV Spot, 'Don't Go to L.A. Live There.' (iSpot)
9) Abercrombie & Fitch Partners with The Trevor Project for #FaceYourFierce Campaign (Globe Newswire)
10) We Belong to Something Beautiful (YouTube)

Related articles

A Feast for the Eyes: Videos That Wow › Nov 1, 2024 How can food and beverage brands engage audience through video?
BHM 2024: Reclaiming Narratives › Oct 22, 2024 How can brands visualise a more positive side of Black fatherhood?
A Decade of Change: Women in the Workplace from 2014 to 2023 › Oct 14, 2024 As brands and marketers continue to shift representation in visuals, it is crucial to examine how far we’ve come during the last decade and what still needs to be addressed.